by Charlie Melvoin
Get in. Get out. That’s my advice to high school seniors: get in to college, then get out of your comfort zone.
My Los Angeles high school was the quintessential pressure cooker. In the months leading up to application deadlines, college counselors guided us towards “reach” schools, “realistic possibilities,” and “safeties,” supposedly tidy categorizations that only served to heighten competitiveness and stress. Class assemblies reminded us to avoid discussing our choices or wearing any college gear.
Then the letters came. Conflicting emotions washed over campus. The dust settled. The school paper published a list of everyone’s final destination; before even graduating it was as if the next step had begun.
So goes life’s achievement track. It’s a race that for some can start as early as a waiting list for preschool, and points toward a college diploma or graduate degree or prestigious job or, quite possibly, never actually ends. Increasingly we’re urged to accelerate – the track offers early admissions here and there, as if we weren’t hustling already. There’s a brokerage ad on TV these days that shows people following a green line they must follow through the end of their lives, extolling the virtue of never, ever, deviating. It’s a different context, of course, but a chilling metaphor.
The proverbial rat race offers no respite, no diversions. It’s a track that seeks to remove any and all gaps – a life without parentheticals.
At this time six years ago, I was as caught up on the track as everyone else. The most caught up, some might say, but luckily I fell prey to the travel bug. Inspired by classic adventure tales – Into the Wild, On the Road, The Motorcycle Diaries, Oh, the Places You’ll Go! – I contacted a student travel company that helped with an itinerary and I headed off for nine months of backpacking around Asia, Africa, and South America, narrating all aspects of the journey on a blog.
As I wandered through cities, villages, and slums, the driving force was a desire to understand how other people live. Major attractions like Mount Kilimanjaro and Machu Picchu were extraordinary, but it was more ordinary conversations that had the deepest impact on me: a Kenyan farmer asking what crops I grow back home, a Thai fisherman explaining how the 2005 tsunami destroyed everything, a Peruvian woman showing me how to cook guinea pig. I was invited to a wedding in China, an elephant funeral in Sri Lanka, and I’m pretty sure a newborn baby in Tanzania was named after me.
I fully recognize the eye-rolling potential in preaching the transformative power of traveling abroad. The British comedy skit aptly titled “Gap Yah” became a YouTube hit for mocking deliberate attempts at self-discovery and the corresponding air of pretension, with such lines as: “I’m in Burma on this kind of spiritual, cultural, political exchange thing.” Admittedly, returning home with long hair and an eyebrow piercing was easy fodder for friends who jokingly asked if I “found” myself. I’d often play along, responding, “Yep, I met the Dalai Lama and now know the meaning of life.”
But the truth is, self-enlightenment clichés aside, that the year put me on a different track. At the end of high school, I was overwhelmed by the thought of more class in just a few months. At the end of the gap year, I was craving just that – a return to structured learning, dorms and dining halls, students my age.
The wonderful thing about the American university system, no matter the campus, is that it offers a uniform cultural experience. I came to realize this very quickly as I corresponded with friends. Regardless of their geographic location or major (or fraternity/sorority), there was an underlying consistency to their odyssey, down to the Ikea lamps and Bed, Bath & Beyond towels. Yes, I wanted that too, but not yet. And far better to take an explicit year off than to treat freshman year as such, which seems to happen all the time.
I have no delusions about the good fortune that enabled my travels. I pooled my bar mitzvah loot and odd job cash, and my parents pitched in the rest, viewing it as an investment with lifelong dividends. Without their support, financial and otherwise, it wouldn’t have happened. So perhaps this is more a call to parents than to students – urge your child to consider a gap year. Or at the very least, allow it. Maybe the cultish success of Eat, Pray, Love is an auspicious sign that moms at least will become more appreciative of the idea of replenishing breaks in life.
Parental understanding is as important as financial support, as meaningful gap years needn’t be costly. Plenty of kids combine work with travel or service, and you don’t have to hang with the Dalai Lama to have a worthwhile experience. And American kids should realize that regardless of prior professional experience, as English speakers we have a mobile skill in demand all over the globe.
There are an increasing number of programs offering gap-year experiences around the world, whether you want to volunteer in Botswana, trek in Nepal or learn guitar in Argentina.
From the “track” perspective – the whispered “This doesn’t look good” – virtually every university permits gap years, and many overtly encourage it. My Harvard acceptance letter floated the idea. The dean of admissions responded to my note explaining my plans by writing, “Wish I could go with you!” Princeton has introduced the Bridge Year Program as a formal gap year application following admittance. It sponsors select students to perform service activities in Ghana, India, Peru, and Serbia, with the confident assertion: “When you return, you’ll enter your first year at Princeton University with a wealth of experience and maturity.”
High schools are catching on as well. My alma mater recently established a gap year fellowship that awards $10,000 to a graduating senior. The application “encourages proposals that embrace independence, a spirit of adventure, and a sense of social justice with a humanitarian perspective.”
I’m currently in graduate school in England, where a “gap yah” is the norm. It’s commonplace to hear people swap stories back and forth, comparing the various ways they filled their year. It’s not what you do, but that you do it. Worst-case scenario is that a stint of boredom makes you even more eager to dive into your next academic setting, but the more likely result is that you become a well-rounded person. We need to balance standardized tests with non-standardized experiences, APs with GAPs. You have the rest of your life to be on track, to follow that green line, so hop off and see where it takes you. The question isn’t why would you take a gap year, but why wouldn’t you?
Charlie Melvoin is a Gates Scholar at Cambridge University pursuing a master’s in development studies. A native Angeleno, he graduated from Harvard-Westlake School and Harvard University.
*Photo courtesy of besighyawn.


Thanks for a moving and inspiring essay. I think about my own life, and while I did not travel as far and as wide as you did, I did drop out of college and live a different life for about 10 years. Best decision I ever made.
Now I see my kids, 19 and 14, on in college and the other thinking about it, both trapped in the rat-race, believing that college is the only path. Ironically, I am a college teacher, so I can’t very well say it’s a bad idea! But neither do I think it is the rich experience that you share in your essay.
I hope my kids can find the wisdom and good fortune to do something like your voyage.
Many regards.
Karl
Thank you for this BRILLIANT piece. Extremely well-written and insightful…I wish my younger brother, who took a gap year, was this articulate and profound. Thanks for writing this!
My son is now 26, in college, working toward an undergraduate degree. He persuaded us to allow him the first gap year after high school, and others followed. He has never been a “track” person, but he has always moved ahead – in his own way. After awhile, we all realized that his life-long avocation, programming, could be his vocation, but it took awhile. He did a little traveling, held real jobs, became a member of several music and dance communities – explored his world and himself. As he rejoins the “track” of a college degree, he also spends time and energy at a campus food co-op, continues to promote and participate in dance and song groups, and is able to think for himself about what’s next. I remember my own experience of following along on the expected track, not figuring out my own path until well into my 50s, and I’m grateful that he will not be going that way!
The dilema I saw as a parent was health insurance. My policy wouldn’t cover my son past age 18 unless he was enrolled as a full time student. On top of that, his coverage would end when he turned 21 so I was feeling a little pressure to have him get as far in school as he could before we had to deal with getting his own policy.
He wanted a year off to explore but we were afraid he wouldn’t be covered if he did that. This was, of course prior to health care reform. Now, I can cover him until age 26.
Just to keep his health insurance, he took the minimum course load to qualify for coverage and didn’t do that well. A few years later, he “found himself” and his grade point average reflects that.
It’s lovely to hear from a young man who has learned so much about life and our collective reason for being. It’s especially sweetened by his time at Harvard Westlake, Harvard, and Cambridge. Once I heard of a man who changed his name to Baba Ram Dass, after he went to India and found that the meaning of life was only to work on spiritual growth, forsaking all the artifices of hierarchy and elitism, forsaking that rat race Mr. Melvoin spoke of, forsaking the materialism that is so rampant in the West. And then he wrote a book about it, which you can buy for only $19.95 right here on the Internet.
I would have believed you, Mr. Melvoin, had you come back and begun a workers’ co-op with the loans you took out for Harvard, or a farm to feed communities in South Central (perfect for a true Angeleno), or, well, anything that didn’t validate the same system that created misery on a global scale. But your returning from an elephant funeral in order to obtain that Gates Scholarship makes trusting you somewhat difficult.
Ray WC, there is always someone like you making sarcastic, cynical and jaded comments on a positive piece that is meant to inspire. Also, I don’t think Charlie Melvoin was trying to plug a book he’s written.
Furthermore, how do you know Melvoin hasn’t come back to start a co-op, or a farm to feed communities? Maybe his purpose in life is not to do any of those things. Maybe his purpose is to write about his experiences and perhaps give someone an idea, motivation, and inspiration to do something.
Should we automatically be distrustfull of his intentions because he took a trip in order to get a scholarship at a good school?
I respectfully disagree. Isolating yourself from society by doing something so hermitic isn’t a valuable contribution…better to work within the system than ignore that it exists…and the education is vital to then achieving those long-term goals. I doubt Melvoin did the gap year “in order” to benefit down the line…it was a bonus that others have seen the value in the experience, but it was valuable in itself.
This is an excellent presentation of one point of view of a GAP year that has added even more to the perspective and success of the young author. I was at that same high school a generation ago and am familiar with the pressure which i am sure is significantly greater now.
My oldest is just now graduating from high school and has had an entire school year abroad as a junior. That brought plenty of challenges, but the positives certainly outweighted the negatives. Next stop for her is University of St. Andrews, Scotland and she is already considering an internship / work year / gap year in Year 3. If she does have a GAP year i hope it will bring as much success as it did for Charlie.